diff --git a/Applications/Segmentation/otbHooverCompareSegmentation.cxx b/Applications/Segmentation/otbHooverCompareSegmentation.cxx
index 603adf43a1663bce870d51ad7b2a0eb6f64f630d..8672055b951ef4abd99cd3e542146268f5103e4b 100644
--- a/Applications/Segmentation/otbHooverCompareSegmentation.cxx
+++ b/Applications/Segmentation/otbHooverCompareSegmentation.cxx
@@ -230,17 +230,17 @@ private:
m_AttributeImageGT = AttributeImageFilterType::New();
m_AttributeImageGT->SetInput(m_InstanceFilter->GetOutputGroundTruthLabelMap());
- m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str());
- m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str());
- m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str());
- m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RM.c_str());
+ m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RC));
+ m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RF));
+ m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RA));
+ m_AttributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RM));
m_AttributeImageMS = AttributeImageFilterType::New();
m_AttributeImageMS->SetInput(m_InstanceFilter->GetOutputMachineSegmentationLabelMap());
- m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str());
- m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str());
- m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str());
- //m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, m_InstanceFilter->ATTRIBUTE_RN.c_str());
+ m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RC));
+ m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RF));
+ m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RA));
+ //m_AttributeImageMS->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RN);
m_GTColorFilter = HooverColorFilterType::New();
m_GTColorFilter->SetInput(m_AttributeImageGT->GetOutput());
@@ -296,7 +296,6 @@ private:
SetParameterFloat("rf", m_InstanceFilter->GetMeanRF());
SetParameterFloat("ra", m_InstanceFilter->GetMeanRA());
SetParameterFloat("rm", m_InstanceFilter->GetMeanRM());
-
}
ImageToLabelMapFilterType::Pointer m_GTFilter;
diff --git a/Code/OBIA/otbAttributesMapLabelObject.h b/Code/OBIA/otbAttributesMapLabelObject.h
index f4f8047aa29acef846dc80f089a1271606dd132c..8a92e23c890edad758a5ac222be9e514d550ce50 100644
--- a/Code/OBIA/otbAttributesMapLabelObject.h
+++ b/Code/OBIA/otbAttributesMapLabelObject.h
@@ -203,6 +203,15 @@ public:
m_Attributes[name] = value;
}
+ /**
+ * Set an attribute value.
+ * If the key name already exists in the map, the value is overwritten.
+ */
+ void SetAttribute(const std::string& name, AttributesValueType value)
+ {
+ this->SetAttribute(name.c_str(), value);
+ }
+
/**
* Returns the attribute corresponding to name
*/
diff --git a/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.h b/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.h
index b9cd24fbb8c50d7bafc24cc27232e6ab59f25c96..9fd007b28b7dabc4cb9a5ff4070fc18bcd4e0bdd 100644
--- a/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.h
+++ b/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.h
@@ -19,10 +19,10 @@
#ifndef __otbHooverInstanceFilter_h
#define __otbHooverInstanceFilter_h
+#include <set>
#include "itkInPlaceLabelMapFilter.h"
#include "itkVariableSizeMatrix.h"
#include "itkVariableLengthVector.h"
-#include <set>
namespace otb
{
@@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ namespace otb
*
* These attributes are handled in a different way than the Hoover scores. The simple presence of an extended attribute in a given region has a
* meaning, regardless of its value. It is assumed that its value always corresponds to an existing region label. This is why these extended
- * attributes are not reseted but removed before computing Hoover instances.
+ * attributes are not reset but removed before computing Hoover instances.
* (see Hoover et al., "An experimental comparison of range image segmentation algorithms", IEEE PAMI vol. 18, no. 7, July 1996)
*
* \sa HooverMatrixFilter
@@ -86,6 +86,7 @@ public:
typedef typename LabelMapType::LabelObjectContainerType LabelObjectContainerType;
typedef typename LabelObjectContainerType::const_iterator LabelObjectContainerTypeConstIterator;
typedef typename LabelMapType::LabelObjectType LabelObjectType;
+ typedef typename LabelObjectType::AttributeType AttributeType;
typedef typename LabelObjectType::AttributesValueType AttributesValueType;
typedef typename LabelMapType::LabelVectorType LabelVectorType;
typedef typename LabelMapType::RegionType ImageRegionType;
@@ -126,35 +127,79 @@ public:
itkGetMacro(MeanRM, AttributesValueType);
itkGetMacro(MeanRN, AttributesValueType);
- /** Attribute name for correct detection */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_CD;
-
- /** Attribute name for over segmentation */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_OS;
-
- /** Attribute name for under segmentation */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_US;
-
- /** Attribute name for missing region */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_M;
-
- /** Attribute name for noise region */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_N;
-
- /** Attribute name for correct detection score */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_RC;
-
- /** Attribute name for fragmentation score (over segmentation) */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_RF;
-
- /** Attribute name for aggregation score (under segmentation) */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_RA;
-
- /** Attribute name for missed score */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_RM;
-
- /** Attribute name for noise score */
- static const std::string ATTRIBUTE_RN;
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_CD, AttributeType, 100);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_OS, AttributeType, 101);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_US, AttributeType, 102);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_M, AttributeType, 103);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_N, AttributeType, 104);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_RC, AttributeType, 105);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_RF, AttributeType, 106);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_RA, AttributeType, 107);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_RM, AttributeType, 108);
+ itkStaticConstMacro(ATTRIBUTE_RN, AttributeType, 109);
+
+ static std::string GetNameFromAttribute( const AttributeType & a )
+ {
+ std::string name;
+ switch( a )
+ {
+ case ATTRIBUTE_CD: name = "HooverInstance_Ext_CD"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_OS: name = "HooverInstance_Ext_OS"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_US: name = "HooverInstance_Ext_US"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_M: name = "HooverInstance_Ext_M"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_N: name = "HooverInstance_Ext_N"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_RC: name = "HooverInstance_RC"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_RF: name = "HooverInstance_RF"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_RA: name = "HooverInstance_RA"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_RM: name = "HooverInstance_RM"; break;
+ case ATTRIBUTE_RN: name = "HooverInstance_RN"; break;
+ }
+ return name;
+ }
+
+ static AttributeType GetAttributeFromName( const std::string & name )
+ {
+ if ( name == "HooverInstance_Ext_CD" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_CD;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_Ext_OS" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_OS;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_Ext_US" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_US;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_Ext_M" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_M;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_Ext_N" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_N;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_RC" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_RC;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_RF" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_RF;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_RA" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_RA;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_RM" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_RM;
+ }
+ else if ( name == "HooverInstance_RN" )
+ {
+ return ATTRIBUTE_RN;
+ }
+ }
protected:
HooverInstanceFilter();
diff --git a/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.txx b/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.txx
index 155fb1b31cc040a86dc0865159dca0ff9e762908..534d21f12f4e31c256e67c868107f50351477975 100644
--- a/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.txx
+++ b/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilter.txx
@@ -23,36 +23,6 @@
namespace otb
{
-/** Hoover Attribute names */
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_CD="HooverInstance_Ext_CD";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_OS="HooverInstance_Ext_OS";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_US="HooverInstance_Ext_US";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_M="HooverInstance_Ext_M";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_N="HooverInstance_Ext_N";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_RC="HooverInstance_RC";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_RF="HooverInstance_RF";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_RA="HooverInstance_RA";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_RM="HooverInstance_RM";
-
-template <class TLabelMap>
-const std::string HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>::ATTRIBUTE_RN="HooverInstance_RN";
/** Constructor */
template <class TLabelMap>
@@ -232,10 +202,10 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
otbWarningMacro("Region "<<i<<" in machine segmentation label map is empty");
}
// reset any Hoover attribute already present
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str(), 0.0);
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str(), 0.0);
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str(), 0.0);
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RN.c_str(), 0.0);
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC), 0.0);
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF), 0.0);
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA), 0.0);
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RN), 0.0);
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
@@ -284,10 +254,10 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
}
// reset any Hoover attribute already present
- labelObject->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str(), 0.0);
- labelObject->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str(), 0.0);
- labelObject->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str(), 0.0);
- labelObject->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RM.c_str(), 0.0);
+ labelObject->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC), 0.0);
+ labelObject->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF), 0.0);
+ labelObject->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA), 0.0);
+ labelObject->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RM), 0.0);
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
@@ -381,13 +351,13 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
double scoreRC = m_Threshold * (std::min(coefT / tGT, coefT / tMS));
bufferRC += scoreRC * static_cast<double>(m_CardRegGT[row]);
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRC));
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRC));
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRC));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RC), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRC));
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_CD.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_CD.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_CD), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_CD), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
}
GTindices.insert(row);
@@ -422,7 +392,7 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
double scoreRF = 1.0 - sumScoreRF / (cardRegGT * (cardRegGT - 1.0));
bufferRF += scoreRF * cardRegGT;
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRF));
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRF));
unsigned int indexOS=1;
for(typename ObjectVectorType::iterator it=objectsOfMS.begin(); it!=objectsOfMS.end(); ++it)
@@ -431,12 +401,12 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
std::ostringstream attribute;
attribute << ATTRIBUTE_OS << "_" << indexOS;
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRF));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RF), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRF));
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
regionGT->SetAttribute(attribute.str().c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_OS.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_OS), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
}
indexOS++;
@@ -518,7 +488,7 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
double scoreRA = 1.0 - sumScoreUS / (sumCardUS * (sumCardUS - 1.0));
bufferRA += scoreRA * sumCardUS;
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRA));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRA));
unsigned int indexUS=1;
for(typename ObjectVectorType::iterator it=objectsOfGT.begin(); it!=objectsOfGT.end(); ++it)
@@ -527,12 +497,12 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
std::ostringstream attribute;
attribute << ATTRIBUTE_US << "_" << indexUS;
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRA));
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RA), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(scoreRA));
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
- regionMS->SetAttribute(attribute.str().c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_US.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(attribute.str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_US), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
}
indexUS++;
@@ -573,11 +543,12 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
bufferRM += static_cast<double>(m_CardRegGT[i]);
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RM.c_str(), 1.0);
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RM), 1.0);
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
- regionGT->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_M.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
+ regionGT->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_M),
+ static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionGT->GetLabel()));
}
}
@@ -593,11 +564,12 @@ void HooverInstanceFilter<TLabelMap>
bufferRN += static_cast<double>(m_CardRegMS[i]);
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RN.c_str(), 1.0);
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_RN), 1.0);
if (m_UseExtendedAttributes)
{
- regionMS->SetAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_N.c_str(), static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
+ regionMS->SetAttribute(GetNameFromAttribute(ATTRIBUTE_N),
+ static_cast<AttributesValueType>(regionMS->GetLabel()));
}
}
diff --git a/Code/OBIA/otbLabelMapToAttributeImageFilter.h b/Code/OBIA/otbLabelMapToAttributeImageFilter.h
index c18de64922858bd2634a5f079ca322a3ba6089ff..b2c55fd23aa8bd8ff07a2590b845ece5dae071fd 100644
--- a/Code/OBIA/otbLabelMapToAttributeImageFilter.h
+++ b/Code/OBIA/otbLabelMapToAttributeImageFilter.h
@@ -92,6 +92,12 @@ public:
/** Fill the given channel with value from the given attribute */
bool SetAttributeForNthChannel(unsigned int channel, const char *attribute);
+ /** Fill the given channel with value from the given attribute */
+ bool SetAttributeForNthChannel(unsigned int channel, const std::string& attribute)
+ {
+ return this->SetAttributeForNthChannel(channel, attribute.c_str());
+ }
+
protected:
LabelMapToAttributeImageFilter();
~LabelMapToAttributeImageFilter() {};
diff --git a/Examples/OBIA/HooverMetricsEstimation.cxx b/Examples/OBIA/HooverMetricsEstimation.cxx
index 79a22aaafaf21ae80fadf5066c27433199304074..06e99dc1dd5ebb297738483b7333430792903d92 100644
--- a/Examples/OBIA/HooverMetricsEstimation.cxx
+++ b/Examples/OBIA/HooverMetricsEstimation.cxx
@@ -164,10 +164,10 @@ int main(int argc, char* argv[])
// Software Guide : BeginCodeSnippet
AttributeImageFilterType::Pointer attributeImageGT = AttributeImageFilterType::New();
attributeImageGT->SetInput(instances->GetOutputGroundTruthLabelMap());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RM.c_str());
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RC));
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RF));
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RA));
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RM));
WriterType::Pointer writer = WriterType::New();
writer->SetInput(attributeImageGT->GetOutput());
diff --git a/Testing/Applications/Segmentation/CMakeLists.txt b/Testing/Applications/Segmentation/CMakeLists.txt
index 86dc2fc1486861b6f899b921b74a198b2f0dd699..ae6ff0254e74242c7719a48697c48e7a3db12ba7 100644
--- a/Testing/Applications/Segmentation/CMakeLists.txt
+++ b/Testing/Applications/Segmentation/CMakeLists.txt
@@ -51,6 +51,8 @@ OTB_TEST_APPLICATION(NAME apTvSeHooverCompareSegmentationTest
APP HooverCompareSegmentation
OPTIONS -ingt ${INPUTDATA}/maur_GT.tif
-inms ${INPUTDATA}/maur_labelled.tif
+ -outgt ${TEMP}/apTvSeHooverCompareSegmentationTestOutgt.tif
+ -outms ${TEMP}/apTvSeHooverCompareSegmentationTestOutms.tif
TESTENVOPTIONS ${TEMP}/apTvSeHooverCompareSegmentationTest.txt
VALID --compare-ascii ${EPSILON_7}
${BASELINE_FILES}/apTvSeHooverCompareSegmentationTest.txt
diff --git a/Testing/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilterToAttributeImage.cxx b/Testing/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilterToAttributeImage.cxx
index 1efe06184733c4759b56ec0704241ff0170790af..0357503539c09dd98882abb6b24961738e006668 100644
--- a/Testing/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilterToAttributeImage.cxx
+++ b/Testing/Code/OBIA/otbHooverInstanceFilterToAttributeImage.cxx
@@ -84,10 +84,10 @@ int otbHooverInstanceFilterToAttributeImage(int argc, char* argv[])
AttributeImageFilterType::Pointer attributeImageGT = AttributeImageFilterType::New();
attributeImageGT->SetInput(instances->GetOutputGroundTruthLabelMap());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RC.c_str());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RF.c_str());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RA.c_str());
- attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, instances->ATTRIBUTE_RM.c_str());
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(0, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RC));
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(1, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RF));
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(2, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RA));
+ attributeImageGT->SetAttributeForNthChannel(3, InstanceFilterType::GetNameFromAttribute(InstanceFilterType::ATTRIBUTE_RM));
WriterType::Pointer writer = WriterType::New();
writer->SetInput(attributeImageGT->GetOutput());